Shelter Island hotels – find & book a hotel in Shelter Island

Shelter Island hotel reservations

Book a hotel in Shelter Island online and save money. Best price guaranteed!

• Shelter Island hotels »
• Browse & Book hotels in United States »

Shelter Island hotels: low rates, no booking fees, no cancellation fees.

Maplandia.com in partnership with Booking.com offers highly competitive rates for all types of hotels in Shelter Island, from affordable family hotels to the most luxurious ones. Booking.com, being established in 1996, is longtime Europe’s leader in online hotel reservations. See the overview of Shelter Island hotels in the following section.

At Maplandia.com you won't be charged any booking fees, cancellation fees (see particular hotel policies), or administration fees – the reservation service is free of charge. The reservation system is secure and your personal information and credit card is encrypted.

We have put together also a carefully selected list of recommended hotels in Shelter Island, only hotels with the highest level of guest satisfaction are included. Many photos and unbiased hotel reviews written by real guests are provided to help you make your booking decision. Luxury hotels (including 5 star hotels and 4 star hotels) and cheap Shelter Island hotels (with best discount rates and up-to-date hotel deals) are both available in separate lists.

Shelter Island hotel deals

With Maplandia.com and Booking.com the best price is guaranteed! Shelter Island hotel deals include also long stay accommodation Shelter Island offers. Take advantage of our exclusive offers and long stay discounts for selected Shelter Island hotels' suites.

Shelter Island hotel reviews

Unbiased Shelter Island hotel reviews written by real guests and many hotel photos are provided to help you make your booking decision.

Shelter Island location

Shelter Island is located in Suffolk County, New York, United States.

Hotels in Shelter Island – sortable overview

• 1. by class ↓
• 2. by name ↑
• 3. by number of rooms ↑

List of all hotels in Shelter Island. By default, Shelter Island hotels are sorted by class: the most luxurious hotels in Shelter Island are listed first. You can change the sorting order using the navigation bar above. By clicking the first (leftmost) button you can interchange the direction of sorting between ascending/descending.

There are separate sections devoted to Shelter Island luxury hotels and Shelter Island cheap hotels.

Shelter Island: list of all hotels

Sunset Beach ****

This beachfront boutique hotel boasts the Sunset Beach Restaurant and Bar and rooms with a flat-screen LCD TV. It is just 2 miles from the ferry to Greenport. Number of rooms: 20.

Hotels in other places nearest to the centre of Shelter Island

Harbor Knoll ****

(in Greenport, distanced approximately 4.0 km)

This waterfront bed and breakfast features free Wi-Fi, a private beach with dock, and individually decorated rooms that offer views of Shelter Island. Island End Golf and Country Club is 2 miles away.

Heron Suites

(in Southold, distanced approximately 4.9 km)

Located at Port of Egypt Marina, this Southold accommodation offers free Wi-Fi and suites equipped with a living area and a full kitchen. Hortons Point Lighthouse is 10 minutes’ drive. All rooms feature a sofa bed, cable TV, and modern decor.

Cliffside Resort Condominiums - Greenport ***

(in Greenport, distanced approximately 5.6 km)

From that Greenport resort with its extensive grounds and private beach, enjoy a magnificent view of the beautiful sunsets over Long Iceland sound. In all areas of the hotel you can take advantage of free Wi-Fi.

A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast ***

(in Southold, distanced approximately 5.8 km)

Relax on the large wrap-around front porch of this Long Island, New York bed and breakfast. Free Wi-Fi and daily continental breakfast are offered. Cedar Beach is 1 mile away.

The Blue Inn at North Fork

(in East Marion, distanced approximately 6.2 km)

The Bed & Breakfast offers free wireless internet and rooms with kitchenettes. The Iceland End Golf and Country Club is 3 minutes by car and the Vineyard Ackerly Pond is 16 miles away.

Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast ****

(in East Marion, distanced approximately 6.5 km)

This historic bed and breakfast features free Wi-Fi, spa services, and individually decorated rooms equipped with a flat-screen TV. Island End Golf and Country Club is less than a mile away.

Quintessentials Bed and Breakfast and Spa East Marion *****

(in East Marion, distanced approximately 6.6 km)

Located in Long Island Wine Country, this charming bed and breakfast offers free Wi-Fi, a full service spa, and individually decorated rooms that feature a seating area, fireplace, and a private deck.

Enclave Inn Wainscott ***

(in Wainscott, distanced approximately 15 km)

Located in the Hamptons in Wainscott, New York, this hotel is 4 miles from East Hampton Beach. It features an outdoor pool, private wooded grounds and rooms with flat-screen TVs.

c/o The Maidstone ***

(in East Hampton, distanced approximately 18 km)

Offering a wide choice of rooms with contemporary décor and a gourmet restaurant on site, this hotel overlooks the historic East Hampton. Each room includes a parking permit for the beach.

Shelter Island car rental

Compare Shelter Island car rental offers of 500+ suppliers

We search over 500 approved car hire suppliers to find you the very best Shelter Island rental prices available. You can compare offers from leading car hire suppliers like Avis, Europcar, Sixt or Thrifty as well as budget rental deals from Holiday Autos, Budget, Economy, EasyCar, or 121 carhire. Choose Shelter Island car hire supplier according to your preferences. The booking process is secured and is made as simple as possible. You don't have to browse through several websites and compare prices to find cheap car hire at Shelter Island - we will do it for you!

Car rental offices near Shelter Island

In the following list, car rental offices nearest to Shelter Island are sorted by the approximate distance from thi city centre.

• Cutchogue (distanced approximately 13 km)
• East Hampton Airport (distanced approximately 14 km)
• Southampton (distanced approximately 19 km)
• Westbrook CT (distanced approximately 25 km)
• Old Saybrook (distanced approximately 27 km)